|
We
all are born with a soft spot for sweetness, and most
people maintain this fondness for sweet foods all
through their life span. In
today's health-conscious society ‘sugar’
has, however, been accused of contributing to more than
a few illnesses from alcoholism to appendicitis,
obesity, hyperactivity, and cardio-vascular ailments.
Increasingly, evidence is emerging to confirm that this
belief has no scientific basis. This editorial is
committed to dismissing
the myths about ill
effects of sugar
on
our health and clarifying the legitimate role of sugar
in a balanced diet. In this particular piece we will
discuss the unfounded information that sugar is
contributory to obesity.
Everything described in here is supported by scientific
reports and in the newsletters that follow; we shall
take up other myths about sugar as a causative to
disease, in progression.
MYTH
UNDER ANALYSIS: SUGAR IS CONTRIBUTORY TO OBESITY
In
order to maintain a healthy weight in the long term, a
person's energy intake from food and drink must be
directly proportional to his total energy expenditure
through physical activity. This, is commonly referred to
as the energy balance. Weight
gain occurs when the caloric intake is higher than the
calories burnt each day in normal activities and/ or
exercise. Eating sugar as such does not cause obesity.
Sugar's linkage to overweight and obesity is in the high
caloric content of many sweetened foods heavily consumed
by people trying to lose or maintain weight.
To
elucidate on this, let us understand the chemistry of
carbohydrate (sugar) and fat storage in the body. The
capacity for carbohydrate storage in the body is
restricted. Intake of excess carbohydrates in the form
of sugar or starch causes a rapid increase in their
oxidation. This phenomenon is not observed in case of
fat. To boot, conversion of sugar to fat is energy
inefficient.
On
the other hand, the capacity for fat storage in the body
is virtually infinite and all the excess dietary fat
that we may consume is readily and efficiently stored as
fat deposits, thereby causing obesity.
Sugars
and other carbohydrates tend to dampen down hunger pangs
without delay and in an efficient manner than most other
foods, especially fat-rich foods.
For example, you feel more full when you eat a
bowl of rice than when you finish up a packet of potato
wafers. The rationale for this is likely to be that fat
(9 KCal/g) has more than twice the amount of calories
per gram than carbohydrate (4 KCal/g). We tend to eat
approximately the same quantity of food at mealtime. If
there is more fat in that mealtime food, we don't
realize it and consequently eat more calories resulting
in the unsolicited weight gain.
In
addition, people who consume a high carbohydrate diet
tend to have a higher metabolic rate. The higher the
metabolic rate the more energy our bodies use even while
resting. This does not apply to fats. Ironically, when
people reduce their sugar consumption they tend to
increase their fat consumption (sugar/fat see-saw).
The
same is summarized in the table below-
|
SUGAR
(CARBOOHYDRATE) METABOLISM
|
FAT
METABOLISM
|
|
Luggage
compartment (storage space) for this in the body
for carbohydrates is limited.
|
Storage
space for this in the body is limitless and extra
fat keeps getting deposited in body.
|
|
Intake
of extra carbohydrate results in its oxidation.
|
Intake
of extra fat results in its deposition in the
body, thereby causing obesity.
|
|
They
dampen down hunger pangs without delay and in an
efficient manner.
|
They
do not dampen hunger pangs immediately or
efficiently.
|
|
Their
one gram consumption yields 4Kcal.
One
teaspoon of sugar has 40% fewer calories than an
equal serving of fat.
|
Their
one gram consumption yields a high of 9 Kcal which
finally contributes to weight gain.
|
|
People
eating more of this have a higher metabolic rate;
meaning more calorie burning.
|
People
eating more of this have a lower metabolic rate;
meaning less calorie burning.
|
The
most likely causes of the increasing trend of obesity
are poor eating habits and sedentary lifestyles.
There is a growing body of scientific evidence that
confirms rising total caloric intake in conjunction with
a lack of physical activity is the single most important
factor in the development of the obesity crisis. In
other words, we are eating the same amount or more of
everything, but exercising less, and- not to miss,
putting the blame on sugar in our diets!
The
World Health Organization (WHO) in its report, "Obesity:
Preventing and Managing the Global Epidemic,"
concluded that the fundamental causes of the obesity
epidemic are sedentary lifestyles and high fat,
energy-dense diets. It did not even name sugar!
The
National Health and Medical Research Council of
Australia (NHMRCA), reports "…a number of studies
have concluded that intake of carbohydrate or even
sucrose has no relationship with obesity, or that the
relationship may even be negative. Children and adults
who ingest large amounts of carbohydrate, sucrose, or
both, have been reported to be leaner than their
peers."
The
cornerstone of the management of overweight and obesity
is the check of food intake, a long-term approach
towards weight loss, and the embracing of a healthy
balanced diet. Moderate levels of sugar in the diet may
help one stick on to a weight-reducing diet more
productively than if they were on a low-sugar diet..
Most weight loss strategies, in spite of everything,
recommend low-sugar regimens.
Sugar
is simply an inexpensive, natural sweetener and also a
nutritive carbohydrate. It is high time that we stop
accusing it of weight gain and obesity. Eating sugar and
sugar containing foods only helps us make our diet more
palatable and enjoyable. Consumption of sugars is vital
for an active lifestyle - not only is it important for
energy reserves for exercise but helps you recover from,
for example, a spell of floor scrubbing. Not eating
enough carbohydrates can lead to poor recovery from
exercise and tiredness.
To
try some of our specialty sugars, you can shop online
sitting anywhere in the world at-
http://www.sugarindia.com/product.htm
Recommended
reading—
Duffy
VB, Anderson GH. (1998). Position of The American
Dietetic Association: Use of Nutritive and Nonnutritive
Sweeteners. The Journal of the American Dietetic
Association. 98(5): 580-587.
Gershoff
S. (1996). The Tufts University Guide to Total
Nutrition. New York: HarperCollins Publishers, Inc.
The
Glucose Revolution Pocket Guide to Sugar and Energy
Jennie Brand-Miller ; Joint Author: Kaye Foster-Powell
For
some of the most exotic and healthy recipes at
http://www.sugarindia.com/
and let us know if you liked them.
Say
yes to sugar, exercise and a healthy balanced diet! For
any feedback on this newsletter, please write to us at-
newsletterfeedback@sugarindia.com
We
wish you luck in achieving your health and wellness
goals!
Sugarindia
Team
|